Lying Abroad: Henry Wotton and the Invention of Diplomacy

Carol Chillington Rutter, Lying Abroad: Henry Wotton and the Invention of Diplomacy. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2026. xi+313 pp., 17 illustrations, £20.

Reviewed by Jeremy Black

If you want a book about Wotton, this is for you. If you want one on the history of diplomacy or its ‘invention’, this is very definitely not, for, as I tried to show in my A History of Diplomacy (London: Reaktion, 2010), there is a much older history and Wotton is of scant consequence to it. There is so much diplomatic history and practice before Wotton’s life, and any discussion must include the Ancient world, the Papacy, China et al.

But, let us, instead, focus on Wotton, and, here, Rutter, Emerita Professor of Shakespeare and Performance Studies at the University of Warwick, has an interesting story to tell. This is one of social mobility, the value of education, the nature of networking, and the importance of faction. Wotton, a secretary to Robert, Earl of Essex, suffers from his fall, but returns to possibility with the accession of James I. This brings a new role to Wotton who, for 1604, is described in a flamboyant style by Rutter, one characteristic of her approach:

Exile, outlaw, intelligencer, traitor: merely Wotton’s most recent roles. Before that: student, secretary, soldier, scoundrel. As human architecture, he’s a man built of many rooms, spacious, cramped, crooked; some sunny, some cast in shadow, others connected by twisting corridors…. He’s travelled across Europe and slept in strange beds. (152)

So excitable style with many words that do not necessarily contribute to scholarship. So also with the descriptions as in ‘the preening Spaniard, Castro, struts down the Scala d’Oro proclaiming the repeal of the Interdict’ (219). As with so many biographies, the role and significance of the subject is exaggerated.

Her book focuses on Wotton’s first Venice embassy (1604–10), but ignores those of 1616–19 and 1621–23, as well as missions to Savoy (1612) and The Hague (1614). This is a pity. The coverage of Venice and Venetian life from Wotton’s perspective is interesting and it would have been useful to see how his views change over his embassies. It would also have been instructive to have comparisons with the other embassies. Not alas here, but this is at least a good read.